This month saw the biggest change in how planning decisions are made since local authority planning committees were established by the Town and Country Planning Act in 1947. The Government has now drastically curtailed the role of elected councillors in making planning decisions. All but a tiny minority of decisions will henceforth be made by non-elected planning officers.
Planning committees are made up of elected local councillors and their key role is to act as the local planning authority, making important decisions on complex and controversial planning issues, including individual applications for planning permission. In practice, committees have for long delegated the great majority of routine decisions – typically around 95% in Wandsworth in recent years - to professional planning officers. The role of planning committees in ensuring transparency and democratic accountability has until now remained crucial.
Governments of all stripes have complained over many years about local planning committees and the decisions they make. In the past two decades in particular, Governments have established ever-more-detailed sets of national policies to promote rather than restrict developments; and to try to ensure that local planning authorities are themselves bound by such development-driven policies. Local decision-making has in this way become increasingly constrained. Decisions must be made in accordance with policies set at national level in the National Planning Policy Framework, regional level in the London Plan, and borough level in the Wandsworth Local Plan. The safeguard for developers is that if they believe that a decision to refuse does not comply with policies in one or more of those documents, they can appeal to the Planning Inspectorate. There is no similar safeguard for local residents or other objectors.
The change made this month takes these constraints a crucial step further. Henceforth, in what the Government misleadingly terms a ‘national scheme of delegation’, local planning committees are now prevented by statute from taking decisions on any but a tiny minority of planning applications. All householder applications, along with minor residential or commercial applications – up to nine dwellings or 1k sq metres - must be delegated to planning officers. This applies even if they are in conservation areas, and regardless of any levels of concern in the community. But yet further, major applications that exceed those size limits – even the very largest ones – are subject to a national presumption in favour of development. They may be referred to the planning committee only if the committee chair and the chief planning officer (who has the final say) agree that they meet a statutory test: that they raise ‘an economic, social or environmental issue of significance to the local area’. If the chief planning officer does not think that an application meets that test, then the decision must be made by him and his staff, with no reference to the planning committee.
Planning officers are employed by councils to make professional judgements in accordance with the policies set at national, regional and local level. They are formally accountable to the elected Council, but they are not themselves elected. Most of the time they get it right: their judgements are sound. But not always. One recent application was to replace the large advertisement structure at the roundabout at the foot of Wandsworth Bridge with an even bigger, and truly ghastly structure. It attracted many objections, and was referred to the Planning Applications Committee, but with a recommendation from officers to approve. The committee, however, took account of the objections, and a democratic decision was made to refuse the application. Under the new rules set by the Government, that could no longer happen; democratic decision-making by elected councillors will no longer be an option in such cases.
The number of planning applications has tended to fall in the years since the pandemic, for many reasons including building cost inflation and rises in interest rates. In the year to June 2026, Wandsworth received just over 2,200 planning applications, and made just over 2,100 decisions, 97% of which were delegated to officers. The Planning Applications Committee has for decades met monthly, and over the past year it has considered an average of around six applications at each meeting. Agendas over the six months up to October included householder applications in conservation areas, changes of use that gave rise to significant numbers of objections on noise and other grounds, a new clubhouse for a tennis club, extensions to commercial premises and so on. At the most, only three or four of all the applications considered over those six months would have been referred to the committee under the new rules. The November meeting has been cancelled for lack of business.
In addition to my role in the Battersea Society, I am currently the Chair of the London Forum of Amenity and Civic Societies, which represents over a hundred societies across London. For more than 18 months the Forum protested vigorously about the Government’s plans to ‘reform’ the role of planning committees. We called it an attack on local democracy. Unfortunately, neither the Government nor anyone else took our protests seriously. Only over the past few weeks, as Wandsworth and other councils have had to amend their constitutions to bring the reforms into effect, have some councillors and others begun to take notice.
Both the Forum and the Battersea Society will keep a close watch on how the reforms work in practice. Under its own legislation, the Government will have to conduct a review of the impact of the reforms and publish a report by October 2028. We shall submit evidence to that review once it is announced, and we trust that many other societies and community groups will do so too.
Michael Jubb
November 2026